NYC COGNITIVE THERAPY
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
    • FAQ
    • CBT
    • TRAINING
  • THERAPISTS
  • SERVICES
    • Individual
    • Group
    • Couples
  • PRESS
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT
  • SCHEDULE APPOINTMENT

"I'm JUst Trying to Help!"

10/25/2026

 
Picture

“I’m Just Trying to Help!”:
Why Good Advice Can Make Things Worse
by Noah Clyman, LCSW-R

Your partner comes home and says, "I had a terrible day."

Your brain says, Finally. A problem I can solve.

Five minutes later, you've suggested talking to their boss, setting better boundaries, updating their résumé, and possibly finding another job. They haven't even finished the story.

You're feeling pretty good about how helpful you've been.

They're getting increasingly irritated.

Finally, they say, "Can you please just listen?"

Wait. What just happened?

When helping doesn't feel helpful

Most of us offer advice because we care. We see someone struggling, we want things to get better, and we genuinely think we have something useful to offer.

And honestly, giving advice can feel good. We're engaged, coming up with ideas, trying to help. So when the other person gets annoyed, we feel hurt or confused.

I see this all the time in couples therapy. One partner eagerly offers what seems like a perfectly reasonable solution. When the other gets frustrated, the one who gave the advice is surprised, confused, and sometimes hurt: "I'm just trying to help! Why are you getting angry?"

Both reactions make sense. One person feels they're showing they care; the other feels unheard or criticized.

But think about what the conversation might feel like from the other side.

Maybe they've already thought about talking to their boss. Maybe they're not ready to make a change. Or maybe they just want someone to understand how hard their day was.

Instead, they're suddenly explaining why your suggestions won't work. You feel dismissed, they feel misunderstood, and now you're both frustrated.

Why is it so hard to just listen?

I'll admit, I do this too. Someone starts telling me about a problem and I'm already working on solutions before they've finished. Kind of an occupational hazard.

Part of it is that watching someone we care about struggle is uncomfortable. Offering advice gives us something to do. We feel useful, and a little less helpless.

We also tend to see other people's problems through our own experience. We're thinking about what we'd do, not what it's like to be them.

Even sharing a similar experience can backfire. A friend tells you they're having trouble in their relationship, and you say, "The same thing happened to me!" Before you know it, you're telling your own story.

You meant to show understanding. But now the conversation is about you.

None of these is necessarily wrong. Advice can be helpful, and sharing your own experience can bring people closer. The question is whether we're responding to what the other person needs, or to our own urge to say something.

The advice can make total sense and still be the wrong response.

What happens when we get curious instead?

Imagine the same conversation going a little differently.

"I'm so overwhelmed at work."

"What's been going on?"

"My boss keeps piling things on me, and I feel like I can't say no."

"That sounds exhausting. What's making it hard to push back?"

Now you're learning something. Maybe your partner is worried about losing their job. Maybe they feel guilty letting people down. Maybe it's something you hadn't thought of.

And instead of defending themselves against your suggestions, they're opening up.

You haven't solved anything. But they feel understood, and that may be exactly what they needed.

Try this the next time someone opens up

Ask what they want. Something like, "Do you want ideas, or do you just want me to listen?" If they want ideas, great. If not, you can always offer them later. People are usually a lot more open to suggestions once they feel heard.

Notice your first impulse. Do you want to give advice? Reassure them? Share your own story?

Before jumping in, try asking one more question. See if you can understand a little more about what they're feeling and why.

Pay attention to what happens. Does the person open up more? Does the conversation go somewhere unexpected?

And notice how you feel. Is it uncomfortable not to offer a solution?

It works the other way too. When you're the one who's upset, try telling people what you need: "I don't need advice right now, I just want to vent."

Sometimes listening is harder than helping. And sometimes it's far more helpful.

If you and your partner keep getting stuck in conversations like this, it's really common, and it can change. 


Comments are closed.

    NYCCT 
    ​BLOG

    SCHEDULE AN
    ​APPOINTMENT

    Archives

    September 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    November 2018
    August 2018
    November 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    October 2016
    June 2016
    October 2015
    August 2015
    May 2015
    July 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    April 2013
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011

NYC COGNITIVE THERAPY
347 470 8870
Monday - Sunday
​by appointment
OFFICE
225 West 35th Street 
7th Floor

New York, NY 10001
EMAIL
[email protected]

contact us
JOIN OUR MAILING LIST
2025 © COPYRIGHT 
​
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
​Design by M I N T
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
    • FAQ
    • CBT
    • TRAINING
  • THERAPISTS
  • SERVICES
    • Individual
    • Group
    • Couples
  • PRESS
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT
  • SCHEDULE APPOINTMENT